Man, people sure are hard on this one. Seems very unfair for a card that costs 0-ER. And yes, you heard me right. This costs 0 effective resources to play. Yes, it technically costs 1-ER, but you can exhaust it that turn to pay for something else, so it's more like you're paying 2 HP now to be able to pay 2 HP later for future resources. If you're playing Scarlet Witch and using Bloodgem for a couple Magic Shields you couldn't have played otherwise, you've already broken even in life.
Yes, you need to exhaust to heal a bit more often, but you know who else exhausts for resources? Jubilee!
Is Jubilee the best hero? No. But tacking her hero ability onto any mystic hero is still potentially useful.
Okay, maybe this is functionally more like a strictly worse version of Venom's hero ability.
But it is free and can help you setup if you don't mind going alter-ego and recovering a bit more often.
What this really asks is what life is worth to you. I would say that a wild resource is a pretty good trade for 2 life, helping you setup quicker and making it less likely you end a turn with dead cards in hand.
This obviously depends on what your priority is though. If your deck is built around maxing out your stats and using your basic abilities, this is going to hamper that strategy. It's also bad for the original Mystic hero, Doctor Strange, who absolutely does not want to be recovering. But for most other Mystic heroes who are building their decks on spellcasting rather than basic activations, trading life to play cards you couldn't otherwise play can often be a powerful and effective strategy.
Yes, it compares very poorly to Clarity of Purpose. But that's because Clarity of Purpose is a leadership card and therefore the single greatest resource generator in the game. This one is 1-ER less and is more situational. But it's still not as terrible as people are making it out to be.
It also doesn't pair well with The Sorcerer Supreme. If you want to be in hero for the game without having to recover, you should use Sorcerer Supreme. If your strategy wants you flipping back and forth, Bloodgem will be the better option.
And it's even better with Adam Warlock who can just heal to max whenever he empties his deck.